Compatibility with CityGML 2.0.0
Table of contents
- CityGML modules and characteristics supported
- Other CityGML modules and characteristics not supported
- Modules and features not supported in CityGML
CityGML modules and characteristics supported
CityJSON implements most of the data model, and all the CityGML modules have been mapped to CityJSON objects. However, for the sake of simplicity and efficiency, some modules and features have been omitted and/or simplified. If a module is supported, it does not mean that there is a 1-to-1 mapping between the classes and features in CityGML and CityJSON, but rather that it is possible to represent the same information, but in a different manner. CityJSON is thus conformant to a subset of CityGML (although technically only CityGML files can be conformant to the specifications of CityGML, see Section 2 of the official documentation for version 2.0.0).
The types of objects stored in CityGML are grouped into different modules, and CityJSON supports these (more details below):
- CityGML Core: all geometries can be represented, Implicit Geometries are supported (called Geometry Templates). However, the
ExternalReferencesare not supported.
Address: everything is supported.
- Building: everything is supported except LoD4 features (interior of buildings) and the concept of Terrain-Intersection-Curve (TIC)
- Bridge: everything is supported except LoD4 features (interior rooms of bridges)
- Tunnel: everything is supported except LoD4 features (interior parts of Tunnel Installations)
- CityFurniture: benches, traffic lights, signs, etc. are all supported
- LandUse: everything supported
- Relief/DTM: only the
TINRelief/TriangulatedSurfaceis currently supported.
Tin(where only elevation points and break lines are stored) is not supported since it would require viewer/applications to have a Constrained Delaunay Triangulator, which is problematic (especially for web-based tools). Also, it is not possible to store areas over a terrain that would support different resolutions (as in Figure 25 of the CityGML standard document).
RasterReliefis also not supported.
- Transportation: most modules supported, except the class “Path” is not used (an attribute to the class “Road” is used instead). We plan to develop a network type in future versions to support modelling a network properly, a simple set of line strings is not sufficient.
- CityObjectGroup: groups of City Objects are supported, but not groups of parts of objects (eg it is not possible to group some walls of a building together)
- Vegetation: everything is supported
- WaterBody: everything is supported
- Generics: everything is supported
- Groups: everything is supported, except that groups can only be for grouping City Objects (and not surfaces or parts of City Objects as it can be in CityGML)
Furthermore, for the Appearance module: the CityGML class
GeoreferencedTexture is not supported.
The CityGML class
TexCoordGen is not supported, ie one must specify the UV coordinates in the texture files.
ADEs (Application Domain Extensions) are also supported, see the Extensions page .
Other CityGML modules and characteristics not supported
- in CityGML most objects can have an ID (usually
gml:id), that is one Building can have an ID, but also each 3D primitive forming its geometry can have an ID. In CityJSON, only specs_cityobjects can have IDs, and each specs_semantics.
- no support for arbitrary coordinate reference systems (CRSs). Only an EPSG code can be used. Furthermore, all geometries in a given CityJSON must be using the same CRS.
- no support for the topological relationships that can be defined, eg relativeToTerrain and relativeToWater
- no ClosureSurface
Modules and features not supported in CityGML
CityJSON has built-in support for the metadata of a dataset (and is ISO 19115-compliant), while, surprisingly, CityGML does not offer that possibility.